Authentication comes first
Klaviyo’s troubleshooting guide is clear that once the message leaves Klaviyo, Gmail, Yahoo and other inbox providers apply their own filters. Those filters look at authentication and reputation, not at how pretty the campaign was in preview.
Set up a branded sending domain (Klaviyo also calls this a dedicated sending domain). It gives you more control over reputation and removes the “via klaviyomail.com” style disclaimer in the inbox. For bulk senders to Gmail and Yahoo, a branded sending domain is required, not optional. Do not use a @gmail.com or @yahoo.com address as the From address. Move it to a domain you own.
Publish a valid DMARC record on the root domain. For bulk senders, Gmail and Yahoo require at least a p=none policy. If you already have a stricter policy, Klaviyo says you do not need to weaken it just to meet that minimum. The root domain of the branded sending domain must match the root domain of the From address — sales@example.com needs a sending domain such as send.example.com, not a random subdomain of a different domain.
Reputation is mostly list behavior
Klaviyo lists the main reputation inputs as engagement, sending volume and frequency, bounce rates, spam complaints and unsubscribe rates. If people do not open or click, or if they mark the message as spam, later campaigns get a colder reception — including flows that used to land in the inbox.
Use Klaviyo’s own operational targets as a watch list, not as a guarantee: keep bounce rates under 1%, try to stay under a 0.3% unsubscribe rate per campaign, and aim to keep the spam-complaint rate reported in Klaviyo below 0.01%. Because Gmail does not send individual complaint data back to Klaviyo, also use Google Postmaster Tools. Klaviyo notes that Google recommends keeping Gmail’s user-reported spam rate below 0.1% and avoiding 0.3% or higher, and that Yahoo requires a rate below 0.3%.
If mail is already going to spam, Klaviyo recommends suppressing a segment of people who can receive email marketing, have received at least five emails in the last 180 days, and have never opened, clicked or purchased. That leaves newer subscribers room to engage. A sunset policy should exist before you are in trouble, not only after.
Klaviyo says sending more than one email per inbox per day is generally risky, and that a burst of volume can get messages rejected or filtered. If both campaigns and flows can hit the same person on the same day, use exclusions or a cap. Sending more often to engaged people, and less often to cold ones, is the official advice — not “just send the flow anyway.”
Content and unsubscribe hygiene still matter
Klaviyo’s content advice is practical: avoid all-caps subject lines and stacks of exclamation points or “free / act now” style phrases; mix text and images instead of sending one giant graphic; limit unnecessary links, especially to other sites; and avoid messy pasted HTML. Make unsubscribing obvious. Klaviyo automatically adds one-click unsubscribe headers to marketing emails. It also suggests considering an unsubscribe link at the top as well as in the footer, because a person who can leave is less likely to hit “spam,” and because long emails can get clipped.
Gmail treats a sender as bulk if they send close to 5,000 or more messages to personal Gmail accounts in 24 hours, counting messages from the same primary domain together — and Klaviyo notes that once Gmail assigns bulk-sender status, it is permanent. If you are at or near that level, the authentication and complaint rules above are requirements, not extras.
After you make changes, give reputation time to recover. Judge progress in Postmaster Tools and in Klaviyo’s deliverability hub, not in one friend’s inbox. Shopify notification emails (order confirmations sent by Shopify) are a different sending path; fixing Klaviyo does not automatically fix those, and the reverse is also true.
What “better” looks like after a cleanup
You want fewer complaints and bounces first, then a slow return of inbox placement for engaged segments. Start by sending to the people who recently opened or clicked, not to the whole list, and keep flows from stacking on top of a campaign the same day. If only one mailbox provider is failing, check Postmaster Tools and authentication for that provider before you rewrite every template.
Bought, scraped or prize-draw lists are a fast way back into spam, even with a perfect branded domain. If a recent import lines up with the drop, stop mailing that group and review how those profiles were collected. Consent has to be real, and the person has to expect mail from your brand. The SMS-consent guide in this series is about a different channel, but the same idea applies: a checkbox the shopper did not understand will turn into complaints later.
FAQ
Do I still need SPF, DKIM and DMARC if I use Klaviyo?
Yes, in the sense that inbox providers still check authentication. Klaviyo’s troubleshooting guide says you should connect a branded sending domain, publish a valid DMARC record on your root domain, and make sure the root domain of that sending domain matches the domain in your From address. A Gmail or Yahoo From address is a problem, not a shortcut.
Klaviyo shows a low spam-complaint rate. Does that mean Gmail is happy?
Not necessarily. Klaviyo says Gmail does not report individual spam complaints to Klaviyo, so a low rate in Klaviyo does not confirm a low rate among Gmail recipients. Use Google Postmaster Tools to watch Gmail’s user-reported spam rate. Klaviyo also notes Google’s guidance to stay below 0.1% and to avoid 0.3% or higher.
Should I keep emailing people who never open?
Klaviyo says repeatedly sending to dormant subscribers can lower sender reputation. If mail is already going to spam, Klaviyo recommends creating and then suppressing a segment of subscribers who have received at least five emails in the last 180 days and have never opened, clicked or purchased, so newer subscribers still have a chance to engage.
Email & SMS Retention with Klaviyo 2026
The course covers Klaviyo list health, flows and the deliverability habits that keep campaigns in the inbox after you have fixed the domain and the unengaged segment.
[ Open the course ]