What the goal is for
Google’s “About customer lifecycle goals” article describes two categories: customer acquisition, which prioritizes bidding that can reach new customers, and customer retention, which is about existing or lapsed customers. This guide focuses on acquisition inside Performance Max, where the same family of settings also exists for Search, Shopping and, for some modes, Demand Gen.
Acquisition is not a promise that every conversion will be incremental. It is a bidding instruction: when Google believes a click is a new customer, it can bid differently than it would for a returning one. That only works if “existing customer” is defined well and if the conversion you optimize toward is a real purchase (for the value-based modes).
| Setting | What it does | Google’s note |
|---|---|---|
| New Customer Value | Bids higher for new customers than for existing ones | Recommended when you have purchase conversion goals. Uses value-based bidding (tROAS or maximize conversion value) |
| High Value New Customer | Bids higher still for high-value new customers | For advertisers already using New Customer Value who want a third tier. You define what “high value” means |
| New Customer Only | Bids exclusively for new customers | Use with a strict acquisition budget or lead-style goals. Run a separate campaign for existing customers |
Set it up without fooling the campaign
- Get a reliable purchase conversion goal in the account, with values you trust. New Customer Value and High Value New Customer require at least one purchase conversion goal. New Customer Only does not require it, but Google still recommends a purchase goal so new versus returning reporting is accurate.
- Upload or sync a Customer Match list of existing customers, and keep it fresh. Google says to define existing customers through first-party data when enabling customer acquisition, using a customer list and the website tag. Follow the current list-size and identifier requirements in Google’s setup and troubleshooting articles.
- Choose New Customer Value unless you have a clear reason to exclude existing customers from this campaign. If you pick New Customer Only, create or keep another campaign that can still serve returning buyers, including brand demand you still want to cover.
- If you use a value-based bid strategy, you can assign additional value to new customers as the interface allows. Be conservative. An inflated new-customer value will make the campaign look aggressive and can overpay.
- Optionally, in the United States, Google notes that Performance Max and standard Shopping new-customer campaigns can be paired with first-order promotions in Merchant Center. That is a promotions setup with its own policies, not an automatic bonus of the bid setting.
A “new customer” who searched your store name may still be a first-time buyer, but that is not the same as net-new demand. Use brand exclusions, as covered in the companion guide, if this Performance Max campaign is supposed to prospect. Otherwise the new-customer report can fill up with people who already knew you.
How to judge the results
Google’s troubleshooting article for the new-customer acquisition goal is the official place to start if reporting looks wrong or the campaign barely moves. After you enable or change the goal, give Smart Bidding time to adjust. Do not flip between New Customer Value and New Customer Only every few days.
When you read the numbers, separate new-customer conversions from total conversions. Blended ROAS can fall even when the campaign is doing the job you asked for, because first-time buyers may be more expensive. That is not automatically a reason to turn the setting off. It is a reason to look at cost per new customer and whether those buyers are actually new in Shopify, not only in the ads report.
If almost no conversions are marked new, the list may be too broad, the tag may be firing for everyone, or returning buyers may already dominate the queries you capture. If almost every conversion is marked new, the list may be too small, stale, or missing identifiers. In both cases, fix the definition before you raise the budget.
Retention goals, such as re-engagement or loyalty-program members, are a different switch and are documented in the same Google article. Do not stack every lifecycle mode on one Performance Max campaign on the same afternoon. Get acquisition honest first, with a clean list, a purchase goal and a brand-traffic check, then decide whether a retention setting belongs in another campaign.
If you also run standard Shopping, you can use the same customer-acquisition setting there, as Google’s eligibility table allows. Keep the definition of an existing customer consistent across those campaigns so “new” means the same thing in every report. And if Shopify’s customer data and the ads list ever diverge — refunds, wholesale buyers, or test orders — clean the list. The bid system will only be as honest as the people you told it were already customers. Refresh the list on a schedule so recent buyers are not repeatedly treated as new. A monthly Customer Match update is a reasonable minimum for most growing Shopify stores with regular repeat purchase activity.
FAQ
Should I use New Customer Value or New Customer Only?
Google recommends New Customer Value for advertisers with purchase conversion goals. It bids higher for new customers while still allowing existing customers. New Customer Only is recommended when you have a strict acquisition budget or non-purchase goals such as lead generation, and Google says you should run a separate campaign to reach existing customers if you use that mode.
Do I need a customer list?
Yes, you should define existing customers with first-party data when you enable customer acquisition. Google’s lifecycle-goals article says to use a customer list and the website tag so bidding can tell new and returning buyers apart. A missing or stale list is how the campaign treats almost everyone as new, or almost everyone as existing.
Will this setting automatically improve ROAS?
Not necessarily, and you should not expect a specific lift. New-customer sales can cost more than returning-customer sales. Judge the campaign on new-customer volume, cost per new customer and overall profit, not only on blended ROAS. Give the campaign time to adjust after you change the goal.
Performance Max Playbook
The playbook covers how to structure Performance Max around real business goals, including new-customer bidding, brand controls and the reporting that shows whether the campaign is actually finding new demand.
[ Open the course ]